Novel

the Sydney Morning Herald.- Sydney

Literary agent Selwa Anthony has lost a high-profile lawsuit against bestselling Australian author Kate Morton, instead having to fork out more than $500,000 for the Shifting Fog writer.

Ms Anthony began NSW Supreme Court proceedings over an alleged breach of contract after Ms Morton suddenly sacked her in 2015 following a longstanding working relationship.

Ms Anthony claimed she and Ms Morton agreed during a telephone conversation in March 2002 that the agent would get a 15 per cent commission of all money earned by the author for the life of the works for which she negotiated the publishing agreement.

Morton, whose five bestsellers have earned her royalties of more than $17.3 million since she came onto the literary scene in 2005, counter-sued, accusing Ms Anthony of depriving her of opportunities as a fledgling author.

During the trial, Morton denied there had been a March 2002 telephone call in which Ms Anthony, a literary agent of 30 years' experience, laid out the terms of their relationship.

Instead, she said she understood over time that Ms Anthony would be paid 15 per cent of any advances she received from publishers.

I acquired it osmotically, I suppose," she said.

The court heard during the trial that Ms Anthony didn't "believe in contracts".

In her lengthy judgment, Justice Julie Ward echoed this, saying there was never any written agency agreement between the pair.

"Ms Anthony’s usual practice was not to enter into written agreements with the authors she represented," Justice Ward said.

The court heard there was a "course of dealing" between Morton and Ms Anthony from 2005 onwards in which Ms Anthony was entitled to deduct a 15 per cent commission from both advances and royalties.

But she found Ms Anthony wasn't entitled to commission after the end of the agency agreement, which had been validly terminated by email in December 2015.

"I do not accept that the evidence establishes on the balance of probabilities that there was ever a conversation between Ms Anthony and Ms Morton to that effect," Justice Ward said.

In her cross-claim, Morton claimed Ms Anthony failed to advise her of the financial implications of granting "world rights" under the publishing agreements entered into with publisher Allen & Unwin for the last four of her books.

She claimed she wasn't told how world rights deals operate or that she could instead have entered into direct agreements with foreign publishers, "territory by territory".

Justice Ward found Ms Anthony had been negligent in this aspect, ordering Ms Anthony to pay $514,000 – the amount Morton was said to have lost by way of additional commission on her fifth and sixth books – plus interest.

"It was clearly a material feature of the world rights arrangements that Ms Anthony’s duties as agent would be reduced to almost nil, whilst Ms Anthony continued to obtain the same rate of commission," Justice Ward said.

"I conclude that no disclosure of this aspect was made to Ms Morton, and that this was a breach of Ms Anthony’s duty to keep her principal informed. I would thus uphold Ms Morton’s cross-claim."

Justice Ward has called for submissions from both parties on costs.

Who's Online

We have 267 guests and no members online

News Most Viewed

  • Ordering
  • Title
  • Most Popular

Elon Musk is looking ...

  Elon Musk has announced that ...

Demonstrations ...

  Coinciding with a demonstration ...

The raids are the ...

  On a night described as the ...

The raids are the ...

  On a night described as the ...

Israel intensifies ...

  More than two weeks after the ...

War in Gaza hits one ...

  The war waged by Israel on the ...

A Canadian study ...

  In a recent Canadian study ...

A Chinese city ...

  Chinese city authorities ...

An expert assesses ...

Academician Gennady Onishchenko, ...

Belarus begins the ...

Today, Tuesday, Belarus began the ...

Biologist: ...

 Professor Ancha Paranova of the ...

Britain: We had to ...

 British Health Minister Matt ...

City uprising lead ...

Manchester City came from behind ...

The summit of ...

  In the latest international ...

The launch of the ...

  Under the theme "BRICS and ...

Demonstrations ...

  Coinciding with a demonstration ...

Global health. The ...

A leading official of the World ...

Observers draw three ...

Following Tuesday's waving ...

The Last Circle

What is the action
  What have we done ...
The world under the
  Today I am trying ...
The Saudi-Iranian
Hello, China is ...
Metavirus and its impact
Written by Ph.D/ Abeer ...
Why should we return to
By the novelist ...
Let’s revive our
written by Abeer ...
The last century was the
By Editor-in-Chief Dr. ...
The African Paradise
Written by|Abeer ...

FOLLOW CASTLE JOURNAL

Astrology

1 June 2023 DAILY HOROSCOPE
Find out more about your ...
1 June 2023 DAILY HOROSCOPE
Find out more about your ...
31 MAY 2031 daily horoscope
Just follow your astral ...
31 MAY 2031 daily horoscope
Just follow your astral ...
23 May 2023 horoscope PART 2
Just follow your astral ...
23 May 2023 horoscope part 1
Just follow your astral ...
5 APRIL 2023 DAILY HOROSCOPE-2
No matter what you feel, ...
5 APRIL 2023 DAILY HOROSCOPE
No matter what you feel, ...
4 APRIL 2023 DAILY HOROSCOPE
LET'S REVEAL WHAT YOUR ...

Locations

  • Address: United Kingdom

        1, Neil J Ireland, solicitor of

         25 Warwick Road -Coventry CV1 2EZ


  •   Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Castle Journal Group